Supervalu Mulls Sale; 'Future Uncertain': Analyst

MINNEAPOLIS — Supervalu on Wednesday said its board of directors would seek strategic alternatives including the sale of all or parts of the company while announcing sweeping plans to slash expenses and capital spending after first quarter financial results fell well below expectations.

The retailer said it would reduce fiscal 2013 capital expenditures from earlier estimates of $675 million to $450 to $500 million and seek additional operating expense cuts of $250 million over the next two years. In addition, the company said it had suspeded its dividend, reached an agreement on a real-estate backed loan to replace its current credit facility, and was withdrawing sales and earnings guidance.

Supervalu shares were trading down by more than 25% in after-hours trading. In a message to employees Wednesday, Craig Herkert, chief executive officer, said the company “has to consider all options to increase the overall value of the company. Our review of strategic alternatives will be broad-based and include looking at the sale or other disposition of all or part of the company," he said.

Herkert said the moves would help Supervalu accelerate a program of price investments begun at its Jewel banner in Chicago. "Our target is to have half of our network priced appropriately to the competition by March 2013," Herkert said. "All banners will see sales-driving investments this year and will be executing the fair price plus promotion strategy by the end of fiscal 2014."

Herkert said net earnings of $41 million for the fiscal first quarter that ended June 16 were "well below plan" and "the miss was across each of our businesses." Earnings were down 45% from the same period last year.

"We need to move faster to execute our strategy," Herkert said. "The competitive environment we're in demands that we do better."

More Supervalu news: Supervalu Seeks Fresh Spark With Executive Shake-Up

Although Herkert said in a conference call with analysts that the company was not considering bankruptcy, analysts said that was one possible scenario, as the company might find it difficult to sell assets or find a buyer, and is poorly positioned if its "fair pricing plus promotions" initiative sparks a competitive response.

"Supervalu's future is highly uncertain given the magnitude and speed of the deterioration [of fundamentals] in a seemingly unchanged environment," said Karen Short, an analyst with BMO Capital Markets.

In a conference call with investors, Herkert said he was confident that Supervalu could work with vendors to improve its pricing, and could cut costs by reducing the inefficiencies brought on by its legacy of acquisitions.

More Supervalu news: Union Files Labor Charges vs. Shoppers

"There are a lot of opportunities to reduce expenses on non-customer-facing initiatives," he said.

He added that Supervalu "feels good" about the condition of its stores, and their ability to compete effectively despite a reduction in capital expenditures.

Supervalu operates the Albertsons, Jewel-Osco, Acme, Shaw's, Cub Foods, Shoppers and other banners around the country, and is also the parent of the limited-assortment Save-A-Lot banner, which analysts have long speculated could be the logical choice for a sale. It also remains the largest publicly owned wholesaler to independents, and the second largest overall.

Discuss this Article 82

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 12, 2012

The logical buyer for svu retail is Kroger they can sell Albertsons to LLC which bypasses antitrust and operate pretty much everything else sell wholesale to awg or c&s along with savealot

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 18, 2012

One bidder is no bidder. Super valu has enough elements and geography to make the parts worth more than the whole today...Kroger makes sense in some instances so does a foreign enity wanting to expand their U.S. footprint.....We'll soon see. Arrogance that was shared by all during the boom years is the culprit. When SV had to sell stock to finance the super fusion which was supposed to be a cashless deal, it looked like a troubled company and it only got worse.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 12, 2012

On the consumer level, through conversations, I have been told that Supervalu has failed not only the customers, but the employees as well. If the company would listen, all the consumer wants is fair pricing, no stupid games, and loyalty card programs that don't make the customer sign up or change information over, and over, and over again. If you could change stratagies to what the CUSTOMER wants, maybe you would stop driving them away and make some money for yourselves, as well as the employees. What has Supervalu got to lose? They're thinking of closing anyway!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 12, 2012

I'm a long time albertsons employee and I am completely shocked about everything that's gone on in the ten years or so I've seen the company get bought twice. If the just lower the prices this will all go away! There are loyal albertsons shoppers

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 12, 2012

EVEN IN THE DAYS WHEN THERE WHERE MANY SV STORES RAN BY THEIR OWNERS LOCALLY SV WAS CLUELESS THEN AND STILL ARE.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 12, 2012

Jeff Noddle deserves credit for taking the company down.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

Agreed. Noodle just cared about his image.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

The problem that SVU has encountered over the years is an inept BOD. Hiring Herkert in 2009 as a turnaround expert was a joke. Sure, he oversaw significant growth in the North and Latin America while at Walmart Americas, but it was with deep pockets and one of the largest corporations in the world that was not in debt. It has been nothing but spin and excuses for the past three years. Why Herkert is still around along with his incompetent "leadership" team amazes me. Negative comp sales for three years in a row, revenue decline of $10 billion, stock decline of close to 80% and net 80 to 100 new Save-a-Lot stores (remember the "double the size of SAL in 5 years" announcement Herkert made in the fall of 2009?). The actions announced yesterday should of occurred three years ago. The one company philosophy did not work...under one banner it could...but not multiple deep rooted regional banners. Wholesale/ independent business should be separate. Save a Lot has incredible potential, but it is currently being misdirected now under another Walmart ex that doesn't get it. The BOD and Herkert should be held accountable as many will pay the price of one bad decision after another.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

As a Save-A-Lot Licensee I see major problems in Save-a-lot's IT department. there are other issues but I believe this is Save-A-Lot's largest problem.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

Albertsons has a very unclear mission, looking as a customer, as some stores are very nice others need a bulldozer. I can agree with others as the pricing games are one day good next day gouge, but what retailer does not do this same practice? We have entered into a 3 and sometimes 4 tier pricing system that is almost impossible for consumers to understand or figure out and that is exactly what the retailers want, get you item, go to the check out and pay with plastic. It never feels the same as pulling out cash and seeing exactly what you are spending. Supermakets today are large and encompass far to many unused products to add to a prouduct count that really doesnt matter as a customer. As a customer, what ever happened to being able to request products I want to buy? Looks like maybe someone should wake up and ask the customers ( people that spend money ) what products they would like to purchase and stop listening to management ( people that get paid from customers spending money ) dictating what people should buy..... The stores have no clue on the next big thing coming, and it is actually going to be consumers will spend where they are treated like they matter.... Good luck to all companies that will not, have not, or can not reinvent themselves in the next dawn to come.
EW Dave - Born and Raised serving the grocery world.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

i was at Kmart when a former Walmart exec took over..lower prices was his answer, sound familiar. He is trying the same tatic here is this all they teach them at walmart or did walmart plant them there? Sounds like a technique that walmart could have in with the rest of their ethic package.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

Rick Cohen (C&S) is waiting in the WHOLESALE wings!!! As for lowly Acme and Shaws, those banners will be sold piecemeal or closed and the ancient names will vanish.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 14, 2012

The big winners in this supermarket retail meltdown will be Ron Burkel and Kroger... chains like A&P, Acme and Albertsons have not kept up with the customers shopping trends and therefore have put their whole existance in jeapordy! The big corporations who have bought and sold these retailers have made a mess of the food retail business because they never invested in R&D and thus, Costco, Walmart, Wholefoods, etc... have gained the business from those retailers.
Look for a different landscape of food retailers to dominate the major metropolitan areas in the northeast in the next 3 - 5 years!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 16, 2012

Store Directors in the Acme division have been instructed to tell shoppers and associates that speculation in the media this week about the possible demise of Acme is greatly overblown, and that Acme is one of the most profitable parts of Supervalu ???

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

Jewel/Osco in the Chicago area has lowered some prices and others they increased during the past month. It is a wash. Go figure. Stand in line at a Jewel store and just listen to the customers complain. Staffing has been cut.. I was in the local Jewel?osco a few days ago and the osco checkout counter had a sign that sasid "ring bell for service" the bell was missing.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

They alienate their shoppers with ridiculously high prices.

They alienate their vendors with threats to delete their items unless they "lean forward" and "invest" by giving them more money, while none of that money ever ends up being put into lower retail prices.

They then alienate the vendors who do lean-forward through terrible retail execution.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

SuperValu will never be a successful retailer until they get all of their banners under the same umbrella. They run their business like 30 different companies and have no brand power or marketing power like a Kroger or walmart ask someone on the street who supervalu is they have no clue

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

ALBERTSON PAID TOO MUCH FOR AMERICAN STORES.THE THEME WAS ONE +ONE WOULD EQUAL 3.
IT NEVER DID. THE COMPANY COULD NEVER AFFORD
THE DEBT LOAD.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

why does albertsons change its name back to lucky's it's better image low price liter .

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

I've been saying this for years, we went through this with Fleming and this is a carbon copy of how they went down.They are in the midst of changing our private label of which the old one was great !! Now we keep having out of stocks and excuse after excuse as to why items are restricted and not available to us and in turn to our customers.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 13, 2012

Both regional and corporate leadership failed to recognize and reward their two biggest assets, customers and associates. Cutting jobs and payroll is not always the answer. Locally JewelOsco is a laughingstock. Failure to react to a changing marketplace many years ago while lining its pockets has cost them their company. Hold the leadership accountable.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 15, 2012

Noddle's ego killed a great company! Most SV execs at the time of the Albertson purchase were light years behind their former retail experience. Herkert is out of his environment and helped push a sick company into what appears to be oblivion. Similar scenario at the former Kmart when Conaway hires a Walmart exec, Schwartz, who helped destroy the once successful Kmart Supercenter

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 15, 2012

Made poor decisions after Flemings demise. Bad store acquisitions and bad decisions on what distribution centers to operate. Letting Flemings Massillon Ohio division go was a mistake. Albertsons was and is a nightmare. Wish their employee's the best!

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 15, 2012

Svu signed alot of. Bad union contracts

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 16, 2012

High prices
dirty stores
employess who don't care
Can't believe you don't want to shop at these stores.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 16, 2012

The Save-A-Lot label could have and should have been a winner but they have changed its direction so many times no one understands what it is any more. Can you say Aldi?

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 17, 2012

Acmwe Markets is doomed. Maybe layoffs soon?

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 18, 2012

Just about everyone in all facets of the Philadelphia area food industry believe that Acme will be liquidated piecemeal,because of overstoring, and similar to Genuardi's the Acme banner will be no more. Cross your finger for the thousands of store associates.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 18, 2012

What about farm fresh stores..how do you think they'll fare through all this mess

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 19, 2012

Farm Fresh (Virginia) and Shoppers (Maryland), even with the current SKU HQ related issues, are performing somewhat better that their sister chains to the North (Acme, Mid Atlantic and Shaw's, New England) which are in the tank. While speculation has Acme and Shaw's being liquidated piecemeal, from what can be salvaged from their carcasses, Farm Fresh and Shoppers, for the most part, might be purchased as a whole by either another retailer or capital venturist such as Yucaipa.

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 22, 2012

As a Shaw's employee for 16 years I would love to get away from Supervalu. They are killing my company

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jul 24, 2012

Yogi Berra - "It ain't over till its over" - Sell Save-A-Lot NOW for $2 Billion, reduce debt by another billion over the next 2 years. Put all the saved interest payments into price reductions. It's all about price, not culture - Herkert was the right choice, Walmart is the model

Post new comment
Sign In or register to use your Supermarket News ID
(optional)

Upcoming Supervalu Events
  • APR. 18
     FY 2013 Results
     
     
  • JUL. 30
    Q1 Results (FY 2014)
     
     

Twitter Facebook Youtube Iphone APP RSS Feeds Google Plus