Internet Coupons Again Subject of Controversy

Sep 3, 2008 6:00 AM, By CAROL ANGRISANI


         Subscribe in NewsGator Online   Subscribe in Bloglines

SAN JOSE, Calif. — Vyrlmkt, the marketing company at the center of an Internet coupon controversy, will stay out of the couponing business for a while, but possibly not forever, its president told SN. “We’re committed to the idea of building a business in which commerce can take place in a viral networking environment,” Harry Soza said. However, if the company does get involved in Internet couponing again, it won’t be anything like the test it ran Aug. 15 in an application within the Facebook social networking site, he added. The Association of Coupon Professionals and the Coupon Information Corp. have lashed out at the test, which they said resulted in distribution of unauthorized consumer packaged goods coupons. The situation arose when Vyrlmkt sought to test a new feature for Facebook by posting coupons for products that had the logos and names of several CPG brands that did not authorize such use. “What we did was wrong, and we will never do it again,” Soza said. “We understand that our tiny experiment was out of line, but it was supposed to be contained.” Still, he said the test proved that the 18-to-28-year-old market is open to commerce via viral marketing. “Our test demonstrated that we have a commerce platform that will be spread in a viral nature,” he said. The test involved 15 offers ranging from 50 cents off to about $6, according to Soza. About 50 to 100 coupons were supposed to be available. But once the test coupons were made available, people starting blogging about them, leading more people to want them. After the allocated amount was depleted, some people used computer manipulation to access additional offers, said Soza. He said the hackers also managed to access and print offers meant to be shown only as examples during sales presentations. ACP executive director John Morgan told SN a consumer sent him 24 high-value coupons, including $16 off an eight-pack of razors and $8 off a six-pack of water. Several of the coupons even had face values that exceeded the product’s retail price. ACP guidelines say no offer should exceed $5. The ACP said the coupons lacked controls to prevent multiple copies and counterfeiting. ACP also blasted Vyrlmkt for not getting permission from the CPG companies to use their trademarks. The legitimate coupons Vyrlmkt distributed had a total face value of several thousand dollars, Soza said. He plans to reimburse retailers for that amount plus several times more. He said he’s also reported the counterfeiting situation to the FBI.

Read More of Today's Headlines

Subscribe / Renew to Supermarket News

Supermarket News

The most reliable source of industry news and insight...in print and online.

Most Viewed News

Read More News

Retail Analytics
Brian Ross

View All Questions

Refresh: A Whole Health Blog

Bob Vosburgh

Bob Vosburgh:

Read More Refresh

Articles by Market
Retail/Financial
Executive Changes
Grocery/Center Store/
Brands
Health & Wellness
In-Store Bakery/Deli/Meals
Logistics
Marketing
Meat/Seafood/Dairy
Nonfoods/Pharmacy/HBC
Produce/Floral
Specialty/Ethnic
Technology
Key Issues
Food Safety/Recalls
Legislation/Regulations
Sustainability/Green
Resources
2009 Trade Show Calendar
Campbell: Innovate
for Impact
Photo Galleries
Profiles & Rankings
Refresh: A Whole
Health blog
RSS
SN Data
Total Access Blog: Expo East
Webinars
White Papers/Studies

Back to Top

Subscribe to SN

Latest Cover

IRI Fast Trends

The Baby Boom generation is long-known to be a trend-setting group, and its impact on the CPG industry is huge. Read about it in the latest IRI Times and Trends report.

SN Free Daily Update

newsletter image

The food trade’s leading daily news service. Register Here

Upcoming Events

January
11-14
IDFA Dairy Forum 2009
International Dairy Foods Association
Disney’s Yacht & Beach Club Resort
Walt Disney World, Fla.
202.737.4332

18-20
34th Winter Fancy Food Show
The National Association for the Specialty Food Trade
Mascone Center
San Francisco
212.482.6440

View All Upcoming Events

Jobs/Classifieds

View All Classifieds

Premium Content

NGA: A Delicate Balance

NGA: A Delicate Balance

Independent retailers, represented by the National Grocers Association, Arlington, Va., are proving they can grow their businesses while facing price competition...

Supermarket News Pinching Pennies

Pinching Pennies

The turbulent economy took center stage this year as the inflated cost of living dictated everything from what consumers ate to where they shopped.

Value Judgment

Value Judgment

In 2009, shoppers will reward supermarkets that offer solutions for making meals and saving money

Supermarket News Making the Cut

Making the Cut

The economy may be in recession, but consumers are still willing to spend on convenient, healthy foods — a trend that has made value-added produce a resilient, growing category.

Cool Running

Cool Running

With the entire country as its laboratory, Wal-Mart Stores has been conducting step-by-step experiments to create the ultimate “green store.”