Are Shoppers Ready to Believe the Worst on Animal Care?

Mar 10, 2008 12:00 PM, By Matthew Enis Editor, Fresh Market, matt.enis@penton.com


         Subscribe in NewsGator Online   Subscribe in Bloglines

Animal rights activism has long been viewed as a bit of a fringe movement, with insufficient mainstream support to matter much to supermarket retailers, or their meat and poultry suppliers. The Humane Society of the United States, however, has certainly been changing that outlook.

Matt Ennis

HSUS is a very well-funded charity with a base of 10 million members, more than 400 staff members and $200 million in net assets, according to the organization’s 2006 annual report, the most recent one published. Its "litigation SWAT team" is led by 12 full-time attorneys and supplemented with more than 100 lawyers working on a pro bono basis.

It has an impressive ground game, too. Most recently, by mobilizing a group of 4,000 volunteers, the organization collected almost 800,000 petition signatures to place their "Prevention of Farm Animal Cruelty Act" on California’s 2008 presidential election ballot. Similar ballot initiative efforts led by HSUS resulted in Florida banning the use of sow gestation crates by pork producers in 2002. Arizona voters did the same thing in 2006. In addition to banning gestation crates, this California measure will likely force the state’s entire egg industry to go cage-free by 2015.

Think what you will of HSUS, but definitely think about them. Their undercover video filmed at the Hallmark/Westland meat packing plant in Chino, Calif., led to the largest beef recall in U.S. history, and amply demonstrated that the group has developed a knack for sparking consumer outrage and getting its arguments in front of congressional committees quickly.

In his Feb. 28 Senate testimony on the Hallmark/Westland case, J. Patrick Boyle, president of the American Meat Institute, described the activity at the plant as a shocking departure from the industry norm, and asked how HSUS "could allow this abuse to continue for almost four months, while it edited its video for release to The Washington Post?"

It’s a legitimate question, but everyone knows the answer already. HSUS waited to get enough footage to make a horrific YouTube clip. They waited to get enough shots of downer cattle being mistreated, in particular, because putting those cows in the food supply is already illegal. The resulting video proliferated across the Internet, shocked consumers and forced the USDA’s hand.

If it’s any consolation, though, consumers are getting past the point of staying shocked for long. In 2004, when Tommy Thompson resigned from his post as Secretary of Health and Human Services, he said, "I, for the life of me, cannot understand why the terrorists have not, you know, attacked our food supply, because it is so easy to do."

In the intervening years, the public has started to understand what he meant by that comment. Our food inspection agencies are underfunded and, in many cases, dysfunctional. Most consumers still understand that the food supply is overwhelmingly safe. But the constant stream of recalls, illness outbreaks and import contamination scares in recent years has made everyone aware that there are serious problems to be addressed in our food system. Unfortunately, that produces an audience that is ripe for believing the very worst about farm animal care, too.

Subscribe / Renew to Supermarket News

Supermarket News

The most reliable source of industry news and insight...in print and online.

Most Viewed News

Read More News

Upcoming Events

Pharmacy & Technology Conference: Aug. 23-27, National Association of Chain Drug Stores, San Diego Convention Center; 703.549.3001.

HBW (Health, Beauty, Wellness) Marketing Conference: Sept. 5-8, Global Market Development Center (GMDC), JW Marriott Desert Ridge Resort & Spa, Phoenix; 719.576.4260.

View All Upcoming Events

Refresh: A Whole Health Blog

Bob Vosburgh

Bob Vosburgh:

Read More Refresh

Articles by Market
Retail/Financial
Executive Changes
Grocery/Center Store/
Brands
Health & Wellness
In-Store Bakery/Deli/Meals
Logistics
Marketing
Meat/Seafood/Dairy
Nonfoods/Pharmacy/HBC
Produce/Floral
Specialty/Ethnic
Technology
Key Issues
Food Safety/Recalls
Legislation/Regulations
Sustainability/Green
Resources
Profiles & Rankings
Webinars
White Papers/Studies
Whole Health Blog

Back to Top

Subscribe to SN

Latest Cover

IRI Fast Trends

Not much remains the same in the food-distribution industry, whether it's the marketing of supermarket departments, the advent of new formats or rapidly changing consumer preferences. See what's changing now in the latest IRI Time and Trends report.

SN Daily Update

newsletter image

The food trade’s leading daily news service. Register Here

Upcoming Events

American Bakery Expo:
Sept. 21-23, 2008,
Retail Bakers of America,
(N.J.) Convention Center,
Atlantic City; 703.610.9035.

View All Upcoming Events

Jobs/Classifieds

View All Classifieds

Premium Content

Upper Crust

Upper Crust

Higher ingredient and fuel costs have led to increased prices in the bread category, but consumer interest in artisan and whole grain breads has held steady.

Supermarket News Secret's Out

The Secret's Out

Discounter Aldi is well-positioned and growing, and doesn’t mind telling you so.

Supermarket News Sharper Image

Asia Major

Wal-Mart delivered a strong message about ethnic retailing when it launched its first-ever Asian American ad campaign three years ago

Supermarket News Show Stoppers

Let the Games Begin

For years China has held the gold medal for nonfood exports sold in U.S. supermarkets

Supermarket News 
Local Flavor

Local Flavor

As food trends go, produce departments are often among the last in line to receive a boost from the latest new craze. Usually, independent chefs take.