Stakeholders in GMO Debate Prepare to Clash Again

Dec 7, 2009 12:00 PM, By ROBERT VOSBURGH Group Editor bob.vosburgh@penton.com


     ShareThis     

In the food industry, there are always culprits. They usually have long tenures, and can even define the decade in which they were topical. In the '80s, it was fat; in the '90s, it was carbs. So far, as we near the end of the first decade of a new century, it would seem to be a toss-up between sodium and added sugar. We still have a year left to determine which one claims the title.

Robert Vosburgh

There are other issues that grab consumer interest but, for whatever reason, never seem to break through the public consciousness and out into the open. This has been the case with genetically modified foods.

Government statistics from 2007 show that the vast majority of the country's commodity ingredients come from GMO crops: 91% of soy, 87% of cotton and 73% of corn. It's estimated that GMOs are now present in more than 80% of packaged food products found in U.S. or Canadian supermarkets.

The coming year promises to bring about a greater, more pervasive awareness of those numbers as opponents of GMOs bring a unified campaign — complete with a non-GMO standard — to the public.

The Non-GMO Project has launched the country's first consensus-based guidelines, which include third-party certification and a uniform seal for approved products. Tests must indicate that the ingredient is below 0.9% GMO — compatible with laws in the European Union. The organization also requires documented traceability and segregation to ensure the tested ingredients are what go into the final product.

Concurrent with this, a new non-GMO website was launched by the Institute for Responsible Technology that provides consumers with a directory of non-GMO brands. The site was developed “for the 53% of Americans who say they would avoid GMOs if labeled.”

The website and the label have the potential to spark a new round of concern among shoppers who are today much more attuned to the ways their food is produced. The growth of the organic (which bans GMO ingredients), local and green product categories reflects a generation of consumers who could be less tolerant of genetic modification.

Yet, this whole issue might still go away (again), if the concept of GMOs is changed. A study written up in a recent New York Times blog noted that when apples from the Midwest, modified to resist apple scab disease, were presented to local consumers labeled “Reduced Environmental Impact,” they scored much higher on the preference scale. The test subjects liked that the apples required fewer pesticides and fungicides, and were locally grown.

The study raises an interesting question: Is genetic modification a problem of science, or of marketing? Ultimately, that's the question to answer: Not whether GMO foods are bad, in and of themselves; rather, does the technology allow us to reduce or eliminate older, more obvious evils?

Respond to SN's Viewpoints online at supermarketnews.com



Acceptable Use Policy
blog comments powered by Disqus

Subscribe / Renew to Supermarket News

Supermarket News

The most reliable source of industry news and insight...in print and online.


WH Refresh Blog

Bob Vosburgh Bob Vosburgh:

When Hiller’s Markets does something, there are no half steps...


SN Editorial Videos

The Lempert Report

Marketing analysis, issues and trends from supermarket industry analyst Phil Lempert.

New Products Hits and Misses

Product reviews from supermarket industry analyst Phil Lempert.

The Role of Technology at Save Mart Supermarkets

Aashish Chandra, senior director of IT Save Mart, talks about his company's approach to technology.

SN Sponsored Videos

Pan-Oston Mobile Innovation Centers Tour

The Supermarket Guru shows the front-end technology you can experience during the tour.

View All

Articles by Market
Retail/Financial
Executive Changes
Grocery/Center Store/
Brands
Health & Wellness
In-Store Bakery/Deli/Meals
Logistics
Marketing
Meat/Seafood/Dairy
Nonfoods/Pharmacy/HBC
Produce/Floral
Specialty/Ethnic
Technology

Quick Poll

Key Issues & Topics
Food Safety/Recalls
Legislation/Regulations
Sustainability/Green
More Topics
Resources
Profiles & Rankings
SN Awards
SN Data
White Papers/Studies
Webinars
Trade Show Calendar
Subscribe to SN
Total
Refresh

Upcoming Events

View More Upcoming Events

Subscribe to SN

Subscribe to SN Newsletter

Premium SN Content

Latest SN Cover

Subscriptions

Get access to print and / or premium online conent.

Register Here

newsletter image

SN Free Daily Update

The food trade's leading daily news service.

Register Here

Safeway: Deflation Cuts Gains

Safeway here believes its price-reduction efforts are beginning to pay off in stronger volume numbers, though an unanticipated spike in...

Mariano Details Roundy's Plans for Chicago

Robert A. Mariano is once again operating in Chicago — this time with his name on the front of the store.

Subscribe to Premium Content Today!

Subscribe to Premium Content Today!

Corporate Finance

Read in-depth coverage of quarterly reports.

Marketing Trends

New promotions, new pricing, new products.

Subscribe to Premium Content